Not all the drama from the show “Amish Mafia” is in front of the camera… there’s plenty in real life.
Esther Smucker, the only main female character on the show, has filed several Protection from Abuse Orders against her boyfriend, I’mir Williams.
In one, she says he told her he would “chop her into pieces and throw her in the garbage can.”
She later stopped cooperating with police and the PFA’s expired.
The issues led to a fist-fight between Williams and Esther’s brother.
Williams pled guilty and paid a fine while her brother was found not guilty.