Auditor General: Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission on shaky financial ground
PITTSBURGH, Pa. – Auditor General Eugene DePasquale today said an audit of the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission shows that the commission is on potentially unstable financial ground that could have serious repercussions on the state’s entire transportation system if the General Assembly doesn’t act soon.
The latest performance audit of the turnpike, which covered fiscal years 2014 to 2016, found that toll violations are increasing, causing the turnpike commission to write off $12 million to $20 million per year. The audit also notes that failing to meet the commission’s unrealistic traffic and revenue projections could contribute to a financial and statewide transportation crisis in the next seven years.
“The turnpike is relying on unrealistic revenue growth projections that should be setting off alarms now and in the near future,” DePasquale said. “On a positive note, our audit found that the commission is following its procurement rules when it comes to awarding contracts and that the turnpike commission is managing its current financial situation.”
Unsustainable legacy of Act 44
The audit found that the turnpike commission is carrying a heavy debt load and is using highly optimistic consultant projections to predict how much money will be coming in each year through 2044 — a combination that could spell disaster.
“Act 44 requires the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission to pay $450 million per year to PennDOT through 2022,” DePasquale explained.
DePasquale first highlighted the problems with the $450 million Act 44 payments in a special report in June 2013, and the legislature took action by passing Act 89 of 2013, which decreased the payments to $50 million beginning in 2023.
“I supported the bipartisan transportation funding reform that became Act 89 because, in addition to improving the state’s infrastructure, it increased oversight of the turnpike’s financial situation,” DePasquale said. “That extra oversight and fiscal monitoring will help create the awareness needed to address the problem before we reach the next transportation funding cliff in 2023.
“In seven years, there’s going to be a $400 million gap in the amount of money PennDOT receives to support public transit agencies in cities and smaller communities across the state,” DePasquale continued. “If the General Assembly doesn’t begin to act now to come up with a plan to make up for the shortfall, the residents who rely on public transit agencies will be faced with severe service cuts — which could result in unaffordable fare hikes.”
For the turnpike commission to be able to make its Act 44 and 89 payments it must increase toll rates every year, and even that may not be enough.
The commission is basing its financial plan on some alarming projections from an outside consultant. The plan for turnpike’s financial future relies on projection calling for a 215 percent increase in toll revenue between 2015 and 2035 and a 44 percent increase in traffic volume through 2044. However, traffic volume has remained relatively flat over the last decade.
“In short, this means the turnpike must continue to raise rates every year and it must increase the number of vehicles that use the roadway by historic levels,” DePasquale said. “As Vice President Joe Biden might say, that’s a bunch of malarkey. There’s no way more people are going to use the turnpike and pay more and more money to do it.”
“The turnpike commission’s consultant is operating under the belief that, ‘if you build it they will come,’ but this isn’t Kevin Costner’s field of dreams. This isn’t a Hollywood movie; at some point people will refuse to pay the toll and start looking for alternative routes.”
In fact, another part of the equation is that the turnpike has to decrease how much it’s spending on capital improvement projects — the re-building plan was already reduced by $1 billion over the next 10 years.
“This is where it gets even more unrealistic,” DePasquale said. “You can’t cut back on construction and increase traffic 44 percent, especially while jacking up the toll rates.
“It’s nonsensical. People aren’t going to pay to sit on the turnpike parking lot,” DePasquale continued. “The entire projection is simply unsustainable.”
The audit concludes that the turnpike commission is relying on long-shot projections to remain financially sound and bond rating agencies are watching closely.
DePasquale urged the General Assembly to begin taking action immediately.
“There are only three legislative sessions left to deal with this issue before it hits, and hits hard,” DePasquale said. “These haphazard funding gimmicks are going to collapse and leave the turnpike and people who rely on public transit systems across the state in a world of hurt if the General Assembly doesn’t act soon to find a long-term, sustainable solution.
“The reduction of Act 44 payments in 2022 might be the light at the end of a dark tunnel for the turnpike commission, but it could mean dark days for people in communities of all sizes who rely on public transit agencies,” he said, noting that many public transit agencies receive about half their operating funds from the state, including:
• Port Authority of Allegheny County;
• Area Transit Authority of North Central PA which serves residents in Clearfield, Elk, Jefferson, McKean and Potter counties;
• Capital Area Transit (CAT) which serves residents in Cumberland and Dauphin counties;
• Erie Metropolitan Transit Authority; and
• Altoona Metro Transit (AMTRAN).
Increasing toll violations
Already, the turnpike commission is seeing an increase in the number of people refusing to pay.
Toll violations — meaning charges for people who don’t pay when they exit the roadway — have increased by 15 percent each year since 2011 (except for 2013). More than 726,000 toll violation notices were sent in 2015.
Also increasing is the amount of uncollected tolls and fees owed to the turnpike. In fiscal year 2015-16 alone, drivers racked up $61.3 million in unpaid toll violations and fees, and nearly $43.2 million remained uncollected by the end of 2015.
The audit points out that other states, such as Maine and Massachusetts, have reciprocity agreements, allowing for a vehicle’s registration to be suspended in a violator’s home state if the violator has outstanding tolls or fees in another state.
“Though the turnpike commission has an extensive, multi-level process involving multiple collection agencies to try to collect unpaid tolls and fees, it lacks the authority to deter drivers from skipping out on tolls,” DePasquale said. “What the General Assembly needs to do is provide the authority to suspend a Pennsylvania vehicle’s registration until outstanding tolls and fees are paid.
“Once we establish the authority to suspend in-state registrations, then a reciprocity agreement with surrounding states should be developed,” DePasquale said.
Following up on findings in the 2013 report, auditors found that the commission continues to allow employees, third-party vendors such as contractors and consultants, and others to travel the turnpike toll free for business and personal use.
“It makes sense for some of these people to travel the turnpike without paying tolls — state troopers, for instance, and workers traveling on turnpike business,” DePasquale said. “But toll-free personal travel doesn’t make sense and needs to end.
“Toll-free travel is an issue that the commission must address immediately,” DePasquale said. “Particularly at a time when every dollar matters for the turnpike commission, the potential for abuse of the system and the cost to allow toll-free personal travel are just too high.”
Turnpike officials agreed with the three findings and eight recommendations in the current audit report. The commission’s response is included in the 73-page audit report which is available online at: http://www.PaAuditor.gov.
PA Turnpike Commission Chairman Sean Logan issued a statement:
“I deeply appreciate the Auditor General’s thorough review along with the recommendations he made. We remain committed to improving our operations to become more efficient while providing safe, efficient travel for our 500,000 daily customers.
“This audit is one of several independent and internal audits — both statutory and voluntary — performed on the Commission’s finances and operations.
“We agree with Auditor DePasquale that our mounting debt, due largely to payments to PennDOT as mandated by state law, is a growing concern, and we are taking steps to address that challenge. We look forward to working with the auditor as well as the legislature to secure passage of meaningful tolling enforcement legislation that will allow all tolling agencies in the state to make sure motorists pay their fair share.
“We owe it to our customers to ensure we are investing their toll dollars wisely. That is why I recently directed staff to conduct a comprehensive reassessment of capital spending to confirm our construction projects are affordable and aligned with our strategic plan. Engineering staff continues the review — sparked in part by our growing debt — which we expect to be complete in the next 30 days.
“I am confident we are on the right track, but we can always do more to improve operations. For that reason, we are grateful for the exhaustive review and report from the Auditor General and his team.”
SOURCE: Auditor General press release