York Co. prisoners claiming to be Jewish for kosher meals

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

A new spike in food costs at the York County Prison has people stumped and looking closely at prisoners claiming to be Jewish. Currently around 140 prisoners say they are Jewish and are receiving three kosher meals a day.  But according to Rabbi Jeffrey Astrachan with Temple Beth Israel, only a small number of Jewish people actually follow a kosher diet.  “My initial thought was, where are all these Jews when they are not in prison?” said Astrachan.

“I think it is high and I think we may have a problem,” said Vice President of the York County Commissioners Doug Hoke, who also serves as the President of the York County Prison Board.

“We got the January 2013 report of the first of the year and the warden noted that the cost for food operation for prison inmates had risen by almost a dollar per meal. The cost of feeding the prisoners absolutely has an effect on our budget and it affects the taxpayers of York county,” said Hoke.

Many believe the prisoners are claiming to be Jewish to get better food. The regular meals at the prison are prepared by staff, the kosher meals are pre-packaged.

Rabbi Jeffrey Astrachan says the belief that the food is better is wrong. “I think the idea of kosher meals being of better quality is a misrepresentation. It’s more expensive to prepare a kosher meal because of the processes that are involved with the slaughtering and the preparation of the food, but it doesn’t necessarily mean that the food is any better,” said Astrachan.

According to the laws of the Torah, the only types of meat that may be eaten are cattle and game that have “cloven hooves” and “chew the cud.” If an animal species fulfills only one of these conditions (for example the pig, which has split hooves but does not chew the cud, or the camel, which chews the cud, but does not have split hooves), then its meat may not be eaten. Examples of kosher animals in this category are bulls, cows, sheep, lambs, goats, and veal. According to the laws of the Torah, to be eaten, a kosher species must be slaughtered by a “Schochet,” a ritual slaughterer. Since Jewish Law prohibits causing any pain to animals, the slaughtering has to be effected in such a way that unconsciousness is instantaneous and death occurs almost instantaneously.

“Vegetables, fruits, would all be kosher so long as they don’t contain bugs or other matter that would have to be expected and removed,” said Astrachan. “If the grains were prepared in the right fashion then a bowl of spaghetti could be a kosher meal. A bowl of salad could be kosher.”

Staff at the prison will be looking into the issue and finding ways to put a stop to the problem.  “My responsibility is to protect the constitution and the rights of the prison inmates but also protect the taxpayers. We are very vigilant about how much money we spend out at our prison and it concerns me if there is any shenanigans going on that are absolutely costing us more money,” said Commissioner Hoke. “Most prisoners when they are admitted have to state their religion when they come in. Now if they come in and state a religion and then change once they’re in prison we’re going to have to come up with procedures to verify that an actual Rabbi did the conversion process. I mean there is going to have to be some validity to their claims so we can prove it and verify it for the taxpayers.”


  • john

    jason i work at a state prison which means i am not allowed to take my meals in to jail i have to eat the same meals the inmates eat and are prepped by inmates. i eat the same "garbage" they eat. so what if they want a clean meal? there inmates not on vacation. my response to them is you lost your rights when you raped killed or destroyed a family with the drugs you sold. suck it up and eat whats in front of you or starve. since its my tax money i want the meals as cheap as possible.

  • HowIgnorantRU?

    The answer is within the article. Basic spaghetti and salad meals are cheap. All-vegetable meals may also be Kosher. You actually provide a cheaper meal designated as Kosher and costs go down or else they suddenly switch faiths.

  • HowIgnorantRU?

    Another possible resolution. Don't buy pre-packaged Kosher. Teach the staff to cook Kosher options. Of course, if you do crime you do not get catered to. You, the prisoner, put yourself into the situation with the bad choices you made.

  • Marsha Peterson

    If they want to adhere to the Jewish faith then perhaps more time in the place of worship? Kill 2 birds with one stone.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.