York County optometrist, former staffer charged in Rx drug scam

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.


A York County optometrist and one of his former staff members  are charged with running a prescription drug scheme following an investigation into the doctor’s prescribing practices by the Pennsylvania Attorney General’s Office.

According to the criminal complaint, Dr. David Wagers, formerly an optometrist at Apple Hill Eye Center, in York, wrote prescriptions in a former employee’s name. That employee, Amanda Peters, would then fill the scripts at various area pharmacies. Peters would then return the pills to Wagers.


In addition to that alleged scheme, Dr. Wagers also allegedly used scripts which were stolen from a previous employer, to write and fill prescriptions for hydrocodone (a Schedule III controlled substance) in his own name.

Investigators said that Dr. Wagers had a Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) registration to prescribe Schedule III, IV and V controlled substances. However, Dr. Wagers did not have any authority to prescribe oxycodone, which is a Schedule II controlled substance.

Dr. Wagers and Peters were arraigned in York County by Dallastown Magisterial District Judge Scott Laird. Peters was released on $5,000 unsecured bail and Dr. Wagers was released on $7,500 unsecured bail.  The case will be prosecuted in York County.

Attorney General Kane thanked the York Area Regional Police for their assistance with the investigation.

Dr. Wagers, 43, of Palmyra, Lebanon County, is charged with two counts of possession of a controlled substance by fraud, one count of prescribing a controlled substance not in accordance with treatment principles, one count of criminal conspiracy and one count of failure to keep records of distribution of controlled substances.

Amanda Peters, 29, of Wellsville, York County, is charged with one count of possession of a controlled substance by fraud and one count of criminal conspiracy.


  • S z

    I will answer your question. Addicts do what they do because they have no choice. They would stop if they could. No article regarding Dr wagers has ever explored whether he is in treatment or in recovery at this time. Also where are the repercussions for the pharmacy is that filled prescriptions Dr wagers was not qualified to write for? What kind of fish in the sea fishing can talk C code own prescription for the doctor that can’t even prescribe it? Did they not run his DEA number? Tim not attempting to deflect responsibility however to do believe the whole should be responsible for what everyone get it and take their part in responsibility.

  • S z

    I apologize to everyone. I was using my voice recognizer and it didn’t work. So my previous comment makes no sense. My point was that the pharmacies that filled oxycodone for Wagers should have run his DEA number and SEEN HE CANT PRESCRIBE THAT LEVEL OF DRUG! Everyone should take responsibility in this case.

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.