Controversy over State Park reservations -Tonight on FOX43 News At Ten

Pittsburgh teen punished for recording alleged bullying wants policy changes, not ‘heads to roll’

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

Photo Courtesy: Shea Love

(FoxNews) A Pennsylvania teenager convicted of disorderly conduct for recording his alleged tormenters in class wants changes to the district’s zero tolerance policy rather than the wishes of his mother, who wants “heads to roll” for the incident.

Shea Love, 40, said her 15-year-old son, Christian, had long been victimized by fellow students in his special education math class at South Fayette High School in McDonald, Pa. So the frustrated sophomore made an audio recording of the alleged bullying using his iPad, which school officials forced him to delete upon learning of the 7-minute segment in February. He was later convicted of disorderly conduct and fined $25 plus court costs.

“What I want is for heads to roll,” Love told “But he said to me, ‘Mom, it might make you feel better if people get fired, but that won’t change anything.’ He said there needs to be more compassion for people and changes to the zero tolerance policy. I want people’s heads to roll, but my son doesn’t and I have to respect his wishes.”

Love’s son has been diagnosed with comprehension delay and anxiety disorders, as well as ADHD. Love said his special needs can be problematic to some.

“He has a low processing speed, the way he does everything is very slow,” she said. “And some people get very frustrated by that.”

Love said her only child hasn’t been the same since the alleged incident. He has lost at least 10 pounds, requires additional therapy sessions and has missed many days of school, she said.

“This has been just devastating,” Love continued. “I’m a single mom — it’s just him and I — and I feel like they were just trying to get us to shut up. Until people started caring, they didn’t care — and that’s pretty sad.”

Love said school officials, including Principal Scott Milburn and Superintendent Bille Pearce Rondinelli, contacted police for a possible violation of wiretapping laws, but did not discipline the students captured on the audio recording harassing her son.

According to a transcript of a March 19 court hearing obtained by the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, the teenager said he made the recording “because I always felt like it wasn’t me being heard.” He said classmates bullied him for several months.

“I wanted some help,” Christian Stanfield said. “This wasn’t just a one-time thing. This always happens every day in that class.”

According to the hearing transcript, district officials forced him to erase the recording and punished him with detention. He was charged with disorderly conduct after police decided the case did not warrant a felony wiretapping charge.

The teen is due to appear in court on April 29 at the Pittsburgh Court of Common Pleas to appeal the disorderly conduct conviction. If those charges are dropped and school officials apologize, Love said she won’t file a civil lawsuit against the district.

“Hopefully they will [apologize], but judging from past actions, I don’t think they will,” Love told “Every day he goes to school now and I just wait for a call. It sucks.”

District officials did not return messages seeking comment on Tuesday.

The boy’s attorney, Jonathan Steele, said he expects a forthcoming civil suit regardless of what happens later this month.

“The damage is done,” Steele told “In terms of an apology, that’d be great, but the student has already suffered psychological damage, emotional trauma and increased therapy, which he truly needs because of what happened to him. He feels like a criminal.”


  • KevSco

    File suit! Hitting them in the pocketbook will get their attention. This kind thing will only stop when the people responsible for preventing it do their jobs or a replaced by persons willing to do their jobs. Further abusing the victims likes this by the school district i absolutely horrible!. Heads should roll! Having been a bullied child in the same circumstance many years ago I can tell you that staff are aware when this behavior is going down and contribute by turning a blind eye, or in some instances acting as though the victim is responsible for the treatment by peers.

  • Drea

    First of all…isnt the recording still in the students ipad cookies? I hope its retrievable. I’ve dealt with bullying of my son is public school and the bullies are never punished. Its horrible. When my child reacts he is the one in trouble. It is a public school….therefore in PA audio is allowed right. I would love to be in this court room! Good for you Christian. A teacher got fired at my sons school for inappropriate actions and getting in my sons face when he got aggravated for having to follow an IEP. They know I mean business now – tread lightly and stand your ground! ♡

  • David

    "district officials forced him to erase the recording and punished him with detention"

    Forced? I would dare any school official to use "force" on my child. I have a hard time believing any judicial system would allow "force" by a school either. This has to be "coercion", not "force".

  • atlaseducational

    Have you thought about homeschooling? Check into it. It would allow your son to go at his pace, for his needs, and the homeschooling community welcomes diverse learners.

Comments are closed.