How do charter schools compare to traditional schools?

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

It has been a back and forth battle within the York City School District about a proposed charter school takeover. The state supports this option, while some parents, staff, and school board members are fighting to stop it from happening.

Charter schools are meant to provide an alternative to traditional schooling. The question is, are they working? The state could take over and push the district to all charter schools.

Tim Eller with the Department of Education said there are currently 165 charter schools across the state.

"There are a large number of them that have excellent academic scores, on the contrary there are some that don't have great academic scores," said Eller.

So how do they compare to traditional schools? State Performance Profiles provide a grade of how schools are doing academically. In Pennsylvania the average public school scored 76.9. The Average charter school scored 65.1.

A score of 70 is considered satisfactory.

In the York City School District, Lincoln Charter Received a score of 59.7. York Academy Regional Charter School 76.9.

Within the traditional schools: Davis School scored 55, Ferguson scored 54, and Jackson School scored 55.3. (See more scores here)

"Some charter schools are doing fine; others aren't. We have been proposing for quite a while that charter schools be held more accountable for academic results," said David Broderic, Spokesperson for the Pennsylvania State Education Association.

Broderic wants to see better oversight for charter schools and more funding, "Pennsylvania absolutely needs to change the way the charter schools are funded. Right now school districts are footing the entire bill and that's because in 2011 the charter school reimbursement program ended." said Broderic.

Currently the Department of Education does not have authority over charter schools because charters are set up through school districts.

"It is about time that we take a good look at that law and make sure charter schools are performing the way that they should be," said Broderic.




  • WPBearcat (@theWPBearcat)

    Fox 43: Keep in mind the charters mentioned can accept or reject students. If YC becomes all charter, they cannot exclude anyone. Their scores would probably not look that different. Thackston and New Hope were all close to the public school’s scores. This report does not really reflect the scope of the issue.

  • Matt

    Anytime you talk about holding public schools accountable the PSEA is up in arms and refuses to do anything. Seems like a double standard to me.

    The PSEA has thwarted progress for far to long and the union should be abolished

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.