No new trial for man convicted in 2014 Lancaster bar shooting, killing 1; wounding 2

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

Lamar Clark

LANCASTER, Pa. –  A Lancaster City man serving an 87-year sentence for killing a bystander when he opened fire at a crowded city bar in 2014 is not getting a new trial, a state appeals court ruled.

Lamar D. Clark was convicted of 3rd-degree murder, aggravated assault, and numerous other counts following a jury trial last year over the November 7, 2014, shooting at Shenk’s Café on East Chestnut Street.

Shenk’s Cafe shooting

Clark, 30, fired five shots, killing 54-year-old Barry Diffenderfer and wounding a man and a woman, according to testimony presented by Assistant District Attorney Mark Fetterman. Lancaster County Judge James Cullen jailed Clark for 38 ½ to 87 years.

Clark, in a request for a new trial, provided three allegations:

– There wasn’t enough evidence to support convictions on two counts of aggravated assault;

– The trial judge should have issued an instruction to jurors on Clark being the subject of a planned robbery;

– Fetterman made an improper statement in closing argument to the jury.

The Pennsylvania Superior Court on Tuesday denied Clark’s request with these explanations on each allegation:

– Witnesses testified that Clark pointed a gun at one victim and his intent of that action transferred to the woman who also was wounded.

– Clark’s defense that he was being set up for a robbery was “vague and speculative,” thus no instruction to the jury was necessary.

– Fetterman’s statement in closing about him, as an officer of the court, not offering any preferred treatment to an eyewitness with a pending criminal case was appropriate and in response to a defense allegation.

Assistant District Attorney Andrew LeFever assisted in prosecution. Lancaster city police Detective Stanley Roache filed charges in the case.