Cocalico held a 21-0 lead over Cedar Cliff at halftime.
The Eagles added to their lead in the third as quarterback Noah Palm hit Austin Landers near the goal line, who then lunged his way in for six points.
The Colts outscored Cocalico 21-10 in the second half but Daniel Engle iced the game with three points.
Final: Cocalico 31 Cedar Cliff 21