Travel softball coach arrested on slew of sexual assault offenses

Joey Sullenberger

CUMBERLAND COUNTY — A coach for the Susquehanna Valley Slam, a traveling girls’ fast pitch softball team, was arrested Friday on a slew of sexual assault offenses, according to Carlisle Police.

Joey Sullenberger, 48, faces five counts of indecent assault, three counts each of corruption of minors and sexual assault by sports official, two counts of aggravated assault, and one count each of sexual assault and hindering apprehension or prosecution, court documents show.

An investigation began on December 22 when Carlisle Police received a complaint from a girl who reported alleged sexual offenses by Sullenberger, her softball hitting coach. It’s alleged that the offenses occurred while the victim was at practice with Sullenberger at the Central Penn Sportsplex in Carlisle.

Carlisle Area School District issued this statement: 

The Carlisle Area School District is aware of the criminal charges pending against Joey Sullenberger.  The charges are unrelated to Mr. Sullenberger’s employment as a softball coach in the District.  Upon learning of the criminal investigation, the District immediately placed Mr. Sullenberger on leave and restricted his access to school property.  He has had no contact with students or the softball program since the District was informed of the investigation.  The District will continue to monitor his case and will take further action as appropriate.  If true, the charges certainly do not reflect the values of the Carlisle Area School District or the high integrity of our staff.  As this is a confidential, personnel related matter, we will have no further comment.

Carlisle Police were able to identify three more victims during the investigation. The department is aware that there may be other victims. The investigation is ongoing.

“The Carlisle Police Department moved swiftly to investigate these allegations balancing the need for public safety and maintaining the integrity of the investigation,” said Cumberland County District Attorney Skip Ebert.  “Our office maintained close contact with Chief Landis throughout the investigation and continue to do so as it evolves.  I thank Chief Landis and his dedicated team of professionals.”

If you or someone you know is a victim, please contact Carlisle Police Detective Thomas Dolan at 717-240-6621 or via email:

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.