Lawsuit filed against Mechanicsburg Area School District following bible controversy

"We tried to bring the issue up behind the scenes. We tried to bring the issue up publicly. But the response of the school district was always the same,” said Randall Wenger, chief council at the Independence Law Center.

And now, lawyers with the Independence Law Center hope the courts will change that response.

It comes after the Bible Club at Mechanicsburg Area High School claims to have been denied permission to distribute bibles during lunch, a move, lawyers with the ILC say violates students’ right to freedom of speech.

“The lawsuit seeks to eliminate several unconstitutional school policies that infringe on the first amendment right of free expression of every student at Mechanicsburg Area High School,” said Jeremy Samek, senior council at the Independence Law Center.

The school, though, says it is against its policy to distribute any literature during the school day.

They couldn’t be reached for comment after the lawsuit was filed because the school is closed due to the cold weather.

They did, however, say in a statement on January 8th, “These rules are established to respect the rights of all students, create a sense of belonging in the school, and ensure there are not disruptions to the school day, and that includes times like lunch.”

But lawyers with the ILC say that’s the problem.

“When students enter a government school, the do not shed their constitutional rights of freedom of speech, which includes offering literature to other students,” said Samek.

And while this is fought in the courts, members of the community have mixed opinions on the issue.

“I just think maybe the school district should sit back and reconsider allowing God in our schools,” said one Mechanicsburg resident.

“I just don’t feel that it needs to be done at school like that. I know everybody has their right to speech, but I don’t think it should be done at school,” said another.

The Bible Club has four leaders- three seniors and one junior.

The lawyers say they hope to have this resolved as soon as possible so those seniors have the chance to express their free speech rights before they graduate.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.